Pembroke Dock: Central

Pembrokeshire local election · 2026-12-08 · candidates ordered by lowest predicted regret

Photo of Claire Francis-Boswell

Claire Francis-Boswell

Conservative and Unionist Party

Who they are

Claire Francis-Boswell was born and raised in Pembroke Dock, brought up on Bellevue Terrace (known locally as Tregenna's Hill) as one of five daughters. According to her candidate statement, she left the town to build a career — describing a 25-year professional career and several years running a business with her husband — before returning home about eight years ago. She is now retired and an active volunteer and town councillor. She has worked with local organisations including the Pater Hall Community Trust, the Warm Rooms, Pennar Hall, Pembrokeshire Pride, the Memorial Park, the neighbourhood police team, Friends of Pembroke Pool and the London Road Management Company. She sits on Pembroke Dock Town Council representing Market Ward and is a member of its Planning Committee. In July 2026 she stood as an Independent in the Pembroke Dock: Market county council by-election, finishing second with 100 votes (25.2%). For the December 2026 by-election she is standing as the Welsh Conservative candidate for Pembroke Dock: Central.

Town Councillor, Market Ward, Pembroke Dock Town Council, 2026–present · Member, Planning Committee, Pembroke Dock Town Council, 2026–present · Independent candidate, Pembroke Dock: Market county council by-election, July 2026 (2nd of 7, 100 votes) · Welsh Conservative candidate, Pembroke Dock: Central county council by-election, December 2026

What they say

Local roots. Community heart. Ready to serve. My name is Claire Francis Boswell, and Pembroke Dock is my home. I was raised on Bellevue Terrace, better known to many as Tregenna’s Hill. I grew up with my family as one of five daughters. Our wonderful parents worked full time instilling within me a strong work ethic, good values and compassion. Like many young people, I later left Pembroke Dock to gain work and build a career outside my hometown — but my plan was always to return to help give back to our community what I thrived within as a child. I went on to enjoy a successful, professional career of twenty-five years. My husband and I also ran a business together for several years, gaining valuable experience in people, organisation, communication, problem-solving and getting things done. Eight years ago, I returned home to Pembroke Dock, and I was proud to live once again back in Market Ward. Since then, I have dedicated my time, energy and passion to working with local people and supporting the community I love, throughout Pembroke Dock. I have endeavoured to work, collaborate with, and hands on support many local organisations and community groups, including Pater Hall Community Trust, Pembrokeshire Pride, Pennar Hall, Town Council, The Memorial Park, neighbourhood police team, Friends of Pembroke Pool, London Road Management Company and many others across our town. I am still an active volunteer and voice within The Pater Hall and was proud to assist in facilitating the commencement of the Warm Rooms five years ago alongside a true force of nature captured by fellow Trustees. The several Warm Rooms across Pembroke Dock have provided a welcoming, safe and supportive space for local people, and I continue to work within them because I believe strongly in practical community support, especially for those who may feel isolated, vulnerable or in need of company. These spaces are ideal venues for sign posting to other organisations where further, specialist help is required or simply a friendly shoulder to lean on. I work closely with local shopkeepers and businesses, helping to advertise and promote what they do. Local businesses are the backbone of our town, and I believe they deserve encouragement, visibility and support wherever possible. I feel we must protect the traditional town whilst assisting organic growth into new areas of retail for our town’s future generations. I am also active in tackling issues that affect the everyday lives of residents. This includes raising concerns around antisocial behaviour, particularly dangerous car driving, and working to highlight the impact it has on our streets and communities. I have also worked to help keep our streets cleaner by drawing attention to dog fouling, supporting initiatives and raising public awareness of the issue. I pride myself on being known to be a local, approachable, passionate and professional person. I care deeply about people. I actively listen. I have genuine empathy. Most importantly, I am a proactive doer — not someone who simply talks about what needs to be done and plays a game of words. My husband and I are now retired from our working careers, which gives me the time, flexibility and commitment needed to serve Market Ward, Pembroke Dock. Standing to become County Councillor for Market Ward, as an Independent candidate is a matter of great pride for me. In many ways, I feel I have come full circle — from being a young girl growing up in Market Ward, to now having the opportunity to serve the very community that helped shaped me and my values. I have great respect for those who have served Market Ward before me, especially Brian Hall, who represented and supported Market Ward for the past three decades. Brian has always been a familiar face to me from visiting the VG shop and garage in Pennar when I was a child to sitting alongside him in Town Council. I have my own, very strong shoes to stand in going forward. What I stand for- I will work for a Market Ward, not an individual party, that is listened to, cared for and represented with honesty, integrity, energy and polite determination. A strong local voice-Making sure residents’ concerns are heard clearly and acted upon wherever possible. Community care and practical support- Supporting places such as our Youth Clubs, Community Halls, Warm Rooms, and the many, many Community groups that help bring people together. Our diverse and busy Market Ward needs to support all the generations within it and be inclusive to all our varied needs. Traditional and modern can align to benefit all. Community cohesion is the key! Cleaner, safer streets- Working to tackle dog fouling, dangerous driving and antisocial behaviour, while encouraging pride in our local environment. I have walked these streets from being a child to an adult, with family and childhood friends to PCSOS and colleague’s. Local businesses and shopkeepers- Helping promote and support the businesses that serve our community and keep our town active. Encouraging new ventures whilst taking learnings from the experienced. Community pride- Supporting the residents, volunteers, groups and organisations who work hard to make Pembroke Dock a better place. Approachable representation- I will continue to be highly visible, active, available and willing to listen — whether the issue is big or small to you. Respect for Pembroke Dock’s past and belief in its future. Honouring our wonderful history and people of our town while working positively for the years ahead. We all accept change and we know it needs to happen but, it should to be in a collaborative and informed manner. My promise- I have worked quietly but passionately in the background for Pembroke Dock since returning home and I will continue to do so. I am not standing for a title. I am standing because I genuinely care. I care about Market Ward. I passionately care about Pembroke Dock. This is my town; this is our town. Our families, friends and neighbours are people that I care about. It would be the greatest of honours if local people placed their trust in me. In return, I promise to continue to give my time, my energy and my passion to representing Market Ward with commitment, honesty and pride. Thank you so much for taking the time to read this.
"I pride myself on being known to be a local, approachable, passionate and professional person. I care deeply about people. I actively listen. I have genuine empathy. Most importantly, I am a proactive doer — not someone who simply talks about what needs to be done and plays a game of words."
source
"I am still an active volunteer and voice within The Pater Hall and was proud to assist in facilitating the commencement of the Warm Rooms five years ago... I continue to work within them because I believe strongly in practical community support."
source
"I went on to enjoy a successful, professional career of twenty-five years. My husband and I also ran a business together for several years..."
source

What they promise

Regret forecast forecast — a projection, not a reported fact

Why voters for Claire Francis-Boswell might regret it:

Why they might not regret it:

The reasoning

Starting point: 12% base rate of regret for Retrospective 'would you vote the same way again' questions on UK votes (2016 referendum, recent general elections), where 81–90% say they would vote the same way and strict 'would switch' regret runs 2–15%, further dampened for low-salience local contests dominated by a personal vote, then adjusted for this candidate.

Independent estimates: 10% regret / 82% would do it again · 15% regret / 72% would do it again · 13% regret / 80% would do it again — combined by averaging in log-odds.

Against this forecast: The strongest case the forecast is wrong in either direction: downward, this is a tiny ward by-election where voters chose a neighbour they personally know, expectations of a single councillor are minimal, and the strict question wording typically yields only 3–5% 'no' — so regret could be far lower than 10%. Upward, she has already changed party affiliation once with no explanation; a second switch, a visible failure on her headline street-safety issues, or a national Conservative scandal before the May 2027 retrospective could make a fifth or more of her voters say they would not vote the same way again.

Raw output from each forecasting pass

Pass 1:

{
  "reference_class": "Retrospective 'would you vote the same way again' questions on UK votes (2016 referendum, recent general elections), where 81–90% say they would vote the same way and strict 'would switch' regret runs 2–15%, further dampened for low-salience local contests dominated by a personal vote",
  "base_rate": 0.1,
  "mechanisms": [
    {
      "mechanism": "Her deep personal roots and visible community work (Warm Rooms, Pater Hall, town council) create a large personal vote; personal-vote supporters are the most persistent and least likely to say they'd vote differently",
      "direction": "decrease",
      "evidence": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1065912921990751"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "As one of 12 Conservative councillors (of 60) on an Independent-led council, she will be unable to visibly deliver her cleaner-streets, anti-social-behaviour and business-support promises, leaving some voters disappointed",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pembrokeshire_County_Council"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "Her unexplained switch from Independent (July 2026) to Conservative, combined with the weak Welsh Conservative brand after Reform's Senedd breakthrough, means some of her voters may come to feel the party label misled them, especially if the national party stumbles before the next contest",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://pembrokeshire-herald.com/143088/new-pembroke-dock-county-councillor-speaks-after-election-win/"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "The next contest is likely only months away (May 2027 full election) and her December voters are a small, motivated by-election electorate (July's neighbouring ward contest saw 28% turnout), so there is little time and little expectation for disillusionment to set in",
      "direction": "decrease",
      "evidence": "https://www.tenby-today.co.uk/news/pembroke-dock-market-by-election-result-925968"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "Her promises are soft process pledges ('work to tackle', 'help promote', 'be approachable') that are hard to falsify, and strict 'would you vote the same way again' wording reliably elicits very few switchers (e.g. 81–90% of Brexit voters would vote the same way)",
      "direction": "decrease",
      "evidence": "https://media.ukandeu.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/UKICE-Exploring-Bregret.pdf"
    }
  ],
  "counterargument": "The strongest case the forecast is wrong in either direction: downward, this is a tiny ward by-election where voters chose a neighbour they personally know, expectations of a single councillor are minimal, and the strict question wording typically yields only 3–5% 'no' — so regret could be far lower than 10%. Upward, she has already changed party affiliation once with no explanation; a second switch, a visible failure on her headline street-safety issues, or a national Conservative scandal before the May 2027 retrospective could make a fifth or more of her voters say they would not vote the same way again.",
  "reasons": [
    {
      "reason": "One Conservative councillor in an Independent-led administration cannot visibly deliver her cleaner-streets and business promises, so some voters feel their vote achieved nothing",
      "weight": 0.35
    },
    {
      "reason": "Her unexplained Independent-to-Conservative switch plus the weak Welsh Conservative brand leaves voters feeling the party label was misleading",
      "weight": 0.28
    },
    {
      "reason": "National Conservative turmoil or a further affiliation change before the next contest would make her voters feel their vote was wasted",
      "weight": 0.22
    },
    {
      "reason": "High expectations for quick visible change in a deprived ward go unmet within the short term",
      "weight": 0.15
    }
  ],
  "endorse_reasons": [
    {
      "reason": "Deep local roots and hands-on community work (Warm Rooms, Pater Hall) make her voters personal loyalists who will gladly back her again",
      "weight": 0.38
    },
    {
      "reason": "Short retrospective horizon to the likely May 2027 contest leaves little time for disillusionment",
      "weight": 0.26
    },
    {
      "reason": "Soft, process-based promises are hard to falsify and expectations of a single councillor are low",
      "weight": 0.21
    },
    {
      "reason": "The small, motivated by-election electorate is composed of core supporters unusually committed to her personally",
      "weight": 0.15
    }
  ],
  "regret_probability": 0.1,
  "endorse_probability": 0.82
}

Pass 2:

{
  "reference_class": "Voters for winning candidates in low-turnout UK local council by-elections, asked within roughly a year whether they would vote the same way again — anchored on 'would you vote the same way again' polling (BSA, UKICE Bregret study, YouGov/UMass), where 85–95% of voters say they would repeat their vote and only ~5–16% express regret even after high-salience disappointments",
  "base_rate": 0.12,
  "mechanisms": [
    {
      "mechanism": "Reform UK is the surging anti-establishment force in Wales (34 Senedd seats won May 2026, ~27% in autumn 2026 polls) and is contesting this by-election; if Reform consolidates the anti-Labour vote by the May 2027 full Pembrokeshire election, tactical voters who backed Francis-Boswell as the best-placed challenger will tell the retrospective they would not vote the same way again",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://www.pollcheck.co.uk/senedd-polls"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "She would take a seat on an Independent-led council (33 of 60 seats Independent, Conservatives in opposition with 12) where a single backbencher cannot deliver her 'cleaner, safer streets', anti-ASB and town-centre revival promises within the ~5 months before the next contest, so expectations set by her 'proactive doer' framing outrun delivery",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pembrokeshire_County_Council"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "Her unexplained switch from Independent (July 2026) to Welsh Conservative (December 2026) can be read by her personal-vote supporters as party opportunism, weakening the 'my own strong shoes, not a party' brand she campaigned on and making some of her own voters feel taken in",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://candidates.democracyclub.org.uk/person/139318/"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "The next contest for the same post is only about five months away (Pembrokeshire's full election is due 6 May 2027), so there is very little time for new facts, scandals or delivery failures to accumulate and change minds before the retrospective",
      "direction": "decrease",
      "evidence": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pembrokeshire_County_Council"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "She has an unusually strong personal vote for a by-election candidate — sitting town councillor, Pater Hall trustee, Warm Rooms volunteer, long-standing local visibility — and personal-vote supporters of active, responsive councillors are the most likely to say they would repeat their vote",
      "direction": "decrease",
      "evidence": "https://candidates.democracyclub.org.uk/person/139318/"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "Retrospective 'would you vote the same way again' questions are subject to consistency and loyalty bias: even after far bigger disappointments (Brexit, US 2024), 85–97% of voters say they would vote the same way, so stated regret will understate any actual switching",
      "direction": "decrease",
      "evidence": "https://media.ukandeu.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/UKICE-Exploring-Bregret.pdf"
    }
  ],
  "counterargument": "The strongest case the forecast is wrong is downward: the retrospective comes only ~5 months after the vote, her supporters are largely personal-vote locals and loyal anti-Labour voters who will not have seen anything to change their minds, and consistency bias in 'would you vote the same way again' self-reports reliably keeps stated regret in single digits or low teens even after genuine disappointment — so regret could plausibly be 0.08 or lower. The strongest upward case is that this is a 25%-turnout four-way by-election won on a fragmented, heavily tactical vote in a struggling ward; if Reform consolidates the insurgent vote by May 2027 and nothing visibly improves in Pembroke Dock, the tactical and protest components of her coalition could push regret to 0.22–0.25.",
  "reasons": [
    {
      "reason": "Tactical anti-Labour voters peel to Reform UK as it consolidates the insurgent vote in Welsh towns by the May 2027 full election",
      "weight": 0.3
    },
    {
      "reason": "As one opposition backbencher on an Independent-led council she cannot visibly fix ASB, dog fouling or town-centre decline before the next contest",
      "weight": 0.25
    },
    {
      "reason": "Her unexplained Independent-to-Conservative switch makes some personal supporters feel she is 'just another politician' and not the independent voice they backed",
      "weight": 0.2
    },
    {
      "reason": "Low-turnout by-election protest and tactical voters revert to their true preferences at the next contest and admit they would not repeat the vote",
      "weight": 0.15
    },
    {
      "reason": "The weak Welsh Conservative brand (fourth place, ~15% in the 2026 Senedd election) becomes a liability her voters cite when the national picture sours",
      "weight": 0.1
    }
  ],
  "endorse_reasons": [
    {
      "reason": "Only five months to the retrospective leaves almost no time for a scandal or delivery failure to sour her voters",
      "weight": 0.3
    },
    {
      "reason": "Her deep personal roots and visible community work (Warm Rooms, Pater Hall, town council) give her a loyal personal vote that will gladly repeat",
      "weight": 0.3
    },
    {
      "reason": "Consistency and loyalty bias in retrospective self-reports means most voters say they would vote the same way again",
      "weight": 0.2
    },
    {
      "reason": "Anti-Labour voters are satisfied simply because their vote unseated Labour in the ward and will endorse the outcome",
      "weight": 0.2
    }
  ],
  "regret_probability": 0.15,
  "endorse_probability": 0.72
}

Pass 3:

{
  "reference_class": "UK voters backing a winning candidate in low-salience local/second-order elections who are later asked whether they would vote the same way again — anchored on 'would you vote the same way again' polling (Brexit: ~85–93% of Leave voters would repeat their vote, i.e. ~7–15% regret; 2024 GE retrospective: 71–77% 'right choice', 14% of Tory and ~23% of all voters 'wrong decision' after a full year)",
  "base_rate": 0.13,
  "mechanisms": [
    {
      "mechanism": "The next contest for the post is the May 2027 all-out county election, only about five months after the by-election — far too short a window for a broken-promise record or disillusionment to accumulate before the retrospective",
      "direction": "decrease",
      "evidence": "https://pembrokeshire-herald.com/154591/four-candidates-confirmed-for-pembroke-dock-central-by-election/"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "Her December voters will largely be personal supporters of a well-known local volunteer and town councillor (Warm Rooms, Pater Hall, town council), and personal votes are sticky — these voters endorse the person regardless of national politics",
      "direction": "decrease",
      "evidence": "https://candidates.democracyclub.org.uk/person/139318/"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "As one councillor on a no-control authority she cannot visibly deliver 'cleaner, safer streets', tackle dog fouling or dangerous driving quickly, so some expectations go unmet — though her pledges are framed as 'work to tackle', which is hard to falsify",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://candidates.democracyclub.org.uk/person/139318/"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "She stood as an Independent in July 2026 promising 'a Market Ward, not an individual party' and is now the Welsh Conservative candidate; if she votes a party line or the national Tory brand sours, localist supporters who backed her anyway could feel the pitch was hollow",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://pembrokeshire-herald.com/143088/new-pembroke-dock-county-councillor-speaks-after-election-win/"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "The by-election follows Labour councillor Beynon's resignation over an attendance scandal, so part of her vote is anti-Labour protest; such negative voters detach easily once the scandal fades",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://pembrokeshire-herald.com/150000/beynon-to-quit-council-after-months-of-scrutiny-over-attendance/"
    }
  ],
  "counterargument": "The strongest case the forecast is wrong is upward: local by-election electorates are tiny and volatile, the right-of-centre vote is split three ways (Conservative, Reform, Restore Britain), so if she wins it may be on ~35% with tactical or second-best voters who will readily say 'no, I wouldn't vote the same way again' when asked — and even national winners' voters show 20%+ 'wrong decision' rates within a year (Savanta). The strongest downward case is that a highly visible, well-liked local figure answering to a tiny electorate at a five-month retrospective simply has no time or occasion to generate regret, putting the figure below 8%.",
  "reasons": [
    {
      "reason": "Only ~5 months to the May 2027 election means no time for a broken-promise record to form",
      "weight": 0.3
    },
    {
      "reason": "Personal-vote supporters of a known local volunteer stay loyal regardless of national politics",
      "weight": 0.25
    },
    {
      "reason": "A single councillor cannot visibly fix dog fouling or dangerous driving, leaving some pledges unmet",
      "weight": 0.2
    },
    {
      "reason": "Her Independent-to-Conservative switch may disillusion localist backers if she votes a party line",
      "weight": 0.15
    },
    {
      "reason": "Anti-Labour protest voters motivated by the Beynon scandal can detach once it fades",
      "weight": 0.1
    }
  ],
  "endorse_reasons": [
    {
      "reason": "Backing a well-known, highly visible local champion delivers exactly what her voters wanted",
      "weight": 0.35
    },
    {
      "reason": "The short interval leaves no record of disappointment to justify switching",
      "weight": 0.25
    },
    {
      "reason": "Winner's halo: voters who backed the winning candidate readily say they'd do it again",
      "weight": 0.25
    },
    {
      "reason": "Conservative identifiers who chose her remain satisfied with their party choice",
      "weight": 0.15
    }
  ],
  "regret_probability": 0.13,
  "endorse_probability": 0.8
}

We'll compare this with what voters say at the next election for this seat.

Earlier forecasts for this candidate
MadeRegret forecastMethodology
2026-11-15 01:43:4218%regret-v1

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:59.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:4290335bcbfb8d35… · verify

What we could not verify

Sources

Claire Francis-Boswell - Candidate for Pembroke Dock: Central in Pembrokeshire local election (Democracy Club) · Pembroke Dock Central by-election candidates published (Pembrokeshire County Council Newsroom) · Four candidates confirmed for Pembroke Dock Central by-election (The Pembrokeshire Herald) · Four-way by-election after Pembroke Dock councillor resigns (Western Telegraph) · New Pembroke Dock county councillor speaks after election win (The Pembrokeshire Herald) · Claire Francis-Boswell stands for Market Ward by-election (Pembroke Today) · Pembroke Dock Town Council - Meet your Councillors · Pembroke Dock Town Council - Meetings and Committees · Claire Francis-Boswell. Pembroke Dock Town Councillor (Facebook page)

Photo of Stephen O'Connor

Stephen O'Connor

Labour Party

Who they are

Stephen O'Connor is a Pembroke Dock town councillor, listed by Pembroke Dock Town Council as the town councillor for Bush Ward, and he is the Welsh Labour candidate in the 8 December 2026 by-election for the Pembroke Dock: Central ward of Pembrokeshire County Council. The by-election follows the resignation of Labour county councillor Joshua Beynon, who left the seat with effect from 31 October 2026 after more than nine years on the council. O'Connor's verified town council service goes back at least to December 2019, when he is recorded as attending and speaking at full council meetings; the town council's ward structure changed in 2022, when the former Llanion ward area became Bush ward. Within the town council he sits on the Finance/Development Committee, represents the council on the Pater Hall Community Trust, and is one of the council's One Voice Wales representatives. No occupation, age or detailed personal biography is published in the sources reviewed, and he does not appear on the town council's list of past mayors of Pembroke Dock.

Town Councillor, Pembroke Dock Town Council (Bush Ward, current; recorded as a town councillor from at least December 2019) · Member, Finance/Development Committee, Pembroke Dock Town Council (current) · Council representative, Pater Hall Community Trust, Pembroke Dock Town Council (current) · One Voice Wales representative, Pembroke Dock Town Council (current) · Welsh Labour candidate, Pembroke Dock: Central, Pembrokeshire County Council by-election, 8 December 2026 (contesting)

On the proposed waste transfer facility in Pembroke Dock: "It has been made very clear, we have to be united as a council and say no to waste dumping in Pembroke Dock. If they want to store waste somewhere, find somewhere suitable because Pembroke Dock says no."
2019-05-30 · source
On proposals for a new primary school in the Pembroke/Pembroke Dock area: "he had a number of concerns about the proposals. A new primary school was not needed in the Pembroke and Pembroke Dock area as there is not an influx of children coming through."
2019-12-05 · source
On the town council precept: "as a Town Council we need to ensure that our Town is kept tidy and does not fall behind other towns in the area and this requires additional funding. Therefore the increase should be supported."
2019-12-05 · source
On the vote of no confidence in three councillors during the town council bullying dispute: "If councillors act below the standard that is expected, they should be reported to the Standards Committee. This is an ongoing investigation at the moment. Until that investigation has concluded I don't think we can take any action... The public have elected them so the vote of no confidence has no relevance to it."
2022-11-02 · source
In a town council discussion of Pembrokeshire Lido plans, he commented that if the pool is a Charitable Community asset, it may be an idea for Pembroke Dock Town Council to look at buying a share.
2023-02-06 · source
On Pembrokeshire County Council's request for town council funding to keep Pembroke Dock Library open an extra day a week: he said it was not the Town Council's role to fund it and that Pembrokeshire County Council were in a "state" with their finances, adding that cuts were going to be devastating for the county.
source
On the purchase of water butts for new allotments at Pennar, he pointed out that although the butts could be pre-filled, there would need to be some way of allowing rainwater to collect and channel into them.
2025-07-10 · source

Regret forecast forecast — a projection, not a reported fact older methodology (regret-v1)

Why voters for Stephen O'Connor might regret it:

Made by an earlier forecast run, which recorded only the reasons.

We'll compare this with what voters say at the next election for this seat.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:58.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:0118248550b83556… · verify

What we could not verify

Sources

Pembroke Dock Central by-election candidates published · Four candidates confirmed for Pembroke Dock Central by-election · Pembroke Dock faces December by-election after Labour councillor resigns · Four-way by-election after Pembroke Dock councillor resigns · By-election called after former Pembrokeshire Cabinet member quits council · Stephen O'Connor - Candidate for Pembroke Dock: Central in Pembrokeshire local election (Democracy Club) · Stephen O'Connor - Who Can I Vote For? · Pembroke Dock Town Council - Meet your Councillors · Pembroke Dock Town Council - Your Council (wards and councillors) · Pembroke Dock Town Council - Meetings and Committees · Pembroke Dock Town Council - Members Interests · Pembroke Dock Town Council - Mayors of Pembroke Dock Town Council · At a Meeting of Pembroke Dock Town Council held on Thursday 5th December 2019 (minutes) · Pembroke Dock: Residents say no to waste facility · Pembroke Dock: Council staff walk out of meeting · Scandal-hit Pembroke Dock Town Council sees alleged bullied staff walk out of meeting · Linking of towns discussed as Pembroke Dock councillors show support for Pembrokeshire Lido · Council asking for £10,000 to keep Pembroke Dock Library open an extra day a week · Pembroke Dock Town Council approves water butts purchase for Pennar allotments

RR

Ray Roberts

Reform UK

Who they are

Ray Roberts is standing for Reform UK Wales in the Pembroke Dock: Central ward by-election to Pembrokeshire County Council, triggered by the resignation of Labour councillor Joshua Beynon on 31 October 2026. The Western Telegraph and Herald.Wales report that he was formerly a member of Restore Britain and Advance UK. No other verified biographical, occupational or political background information about him was found in publicly available sources; the council's candidate list and local news coverage give his name, ward and party description only.

Candidate, Reform UK Wales, Pembroke Dock: Central by-election, Pembrokeshire County Council, 2026 (contesting 8 December 2026) · Former member of Restore Britain (per Western Telegraph / Herald.Wales, November 2026) · Former member of Advance UK (per Western Telegraph / Herald.Wales, November 2026)

Regret forecast forecast — a projection, not a reported fact older methodology (regret-v1)

Why voters for Ray Roberts might regret it:

Made by an earlier forecast run, which recorded only the reasons.

We'll compare this with what voters say at the next election for this seat.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:58.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:c169d538a5a80e17… · verify

What we could not verify

Sources

Pembroke Dock Central by-election candidates published – Pembrokeshire County Council · By-election notice issued for Pembroke Dock Central ward – Pembrokeshire County Council · Four candidates confirmed for Pembroke Dock Central by-election – The Pembrokeshire Herald · Four-way by-election after Pembroke Dock councillor resigns – Western Telegraph · By-election called after former Pembrokeshire Cabinet member quits council – Herald.Wales · Ray Roberts – Democracy Club candidate record · Ray Roberts for Pembroke Dock: Central – Who Can I Vote For? · New Christmas song about controversial 'Instagram-friendly' bridge in Welsh town – WalesOnline · Reform comes fourth in Pembrokeshire by-election – Nation.Cymru

TD

Terence David Jones

Restore Britain

Who they are

Terence David Jones is listed by Pembrokeshire County Council as the Restore Britain candidate for the Pembroke Dock: Central ward in the county council by-election of 8 December 2026, alongside Welsh Conservative Claire Francis-Boswell, Welsh Labour's Stephen O'Connor and Reform UK Wales' Ray Roberts. The by-election was triggered by the resignation on 31 October 2026 of Labour councillor Joshua Beynon, who had represented Pembroke Dock: Central since 2022 and had served as the council's cabinet member for finance. Beyond his nomination and party affiliation, no biographical details, campaign statements, election literature or contact information for Mr Jones were found in public sources; his Democracy Club record contains no photo, age, gender, social media links or statement to voters.

Candidate, Restore Britain, Pembroke Dock: Central by-election, Pembrokeshire County Council, 2026

Regret forecast forecast — a projection, not a reported fact older methodology (regret-v1)

Why voters for Terence David Jones might regret it:

Made by an earlier forecast run, which recorded only the reasons.

We'll compare this with what voters say at the next election for this seat.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:59.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:527f403e37f1400b… · verify

What we could not verify

Sources

Pembroke Dock Central by-election candidates published – Pembrokeshire County Council News · By-election notice issued for Pembroke Dock Central ward – Pembrokeshire County Council News · Four candidates confirmed for Pembroke Dock Central by-election – The Pembrokeshire Herald · Four-way by-election after Pembroke Dock councillor resigns – Western Telegraph · By-election called after former Pembrokeshire Cabinet member quits council – Herald.Wales · Terence David Jones – Democracy Club Candidates · Terence David Jones – Who Can I Vote For? · Restore Britain – Wikipedia · 2022 Pembrokeshire County Council election – Wikipedia · Man faces losing dream home after 'bonkers' decision – The Pembrokeshire Herald

If elected, then…

Predictions of what would happen if these candidates are elected. Each one reads "if the candidate is elected, then …" — the framing is already here, so write just the outcome. Anyone can post one; it must be specific and falsifiable or it is not posted. Upvote what you think is relevant, downvote what isn't — the most upvoted predictions are analysed for every candidate on the daily run.

Post a prediction

If the candidate is elected, then…

No predictions yet.

P(regret|vote)