Steve Shaw
Liberal Democrats
Who they are
Steve Shaw is a retired Royal Navy Commander who says he spent 40 years in the Royal Navy. He is a co-founder of Project 71, a not-for-profit organisation that supports Second World War veterans, and is chair of the Portchester Volunteer Marching Band. He describes Portchester as his home and is standing for the Liberal Democrats in the Portchester Wicor by-election to Fareham Borough Council on 19 November 2026. The by-election follows the resignation of Cllr Rob Turner, who was elected for the Liberal Democrats in May 2026 but left the party group in July 2026 citing health reasons and later resigned.
Retired Royal Navy Commander, Royal Navy, 40 years (specific dates not stated in sources) · Co-founder, Project 71 (not-for-profit supporting WW2 veterans), active by 2023–present · Chair, Portchester Volunteer Marching Band, 2026–present · Director, own events company (per Gazette report; dates not stated)
What they say
I'm proud to call Portchester my home and want to give something back to the community I care about. As a retired Royal Navy Commander with a strong background in community service, I know the importance of hard work, teamwork and getting things done. If elected, I'll work alongside local Liberal Democrat councillor Paul Nother to stand up for residents, protect our green spaces, challenge inappropriate development and make sure Portchester Wicor gets the attention it deserves. I'm asking for your vote on 19 November so I can work hard for Portchester all year round, not just at election time.
Statement to voters: "I'm proud to call Portchester my home and want to give something back to the community I care about. As a retired Royal Navy Commander with a strong background in community service, I know the importance of hard work, teamwork and getting things done. If elected, I'll work alongside local Liberal Democrat councillor Paul Nother to stand up for residents, protect our green spaces, challenge inappropriate development and make sure Portchester Wicor gets the attention it deserves. I'm asking for your vote on 19 November so I can work hard for Portchester all year round, not just at election time."
2026-10-18 · source
Said he wants to continue serving his community after spending 40 years in the Royal Navy, and that supporting veterans is particularly important to him alongside everyday issues affecting residents.
source
Stated his priorities include getting roads and pavements repaired, protecting green spaces and supporting charities and community groups, and said he wants to be a councillor who listens to residents and works throughout the year.
source
Backed a Liberal Democrat proposal to install bollards at High View Park to prevent unauthorised encampments, calling it "common sense".
source
As co-founder of Project 71, spoke about supporting WW2 veterans, including warning that Winter Fuel Payment cuts would force some veterans to choose between "eating and heating".
source
What they promise
- To work alongside local Liberal Democrat councillor Paul Nother to stand up for residents, protect green spaces, challenge inappropriate development and make sure Portchester Wicor gets the attention it deserves. source
- To work hard for Portchester all year round, not just at election time. source
- To prioritise getting roads and pavements repaired, protecting green spaces and supporting charities and community groups. source
Regret forecast forecast — a projection, not a reported fact
Why voters for Steve Shaw might regret it:
- As a lone opposition backbencher he cannot deliver road repairs or planning changes against the Conservative majority, so delivery-focused voters feel their vote achieved nothing
- After the previous Lib Dem quit within months, voters expect visible year-round work and notice if it does not materialise
- Anti-development and tactical voters see no change to local building plans over the 2-4 year horizon
- Casework demands outstrip one MP's power and he is blamed for unkept local promises as the honeymoon fades
- National political tides shift over the term and sour some of his softer supporters
Why they might not regret it:
- Habitual Lib Dem identifiers in a Lib Dem-held ward simply repeat their vote when asked
- His visible community presence (marching band chair, Project 71 veterans work) sustains personal satisfaction among his voters
- Disappointment with council decisions is attributed to the Conservative ruling group, not to Shaw
- Low-salience local vote: few voters will tell a surveyor they'd change such a small-stakes choice
The reasoning
Starting point: 10% base rate of regret for Voters asked after the fact whether they would vote the same way again in low-salience UK votes (2016 Brexit referendum repeat-vote polling: ~85-93% would repeat, so ~7-15% would not; general 'vote choice regret' surveys: ~2-13% explicit switchers), applied to a UK local council ward vote, then adjusted for this candidate.
- + Shaw would join a small Lib Dem group (7 of 32 seats) on a Conservative-run council (22 seats), so his headline promises — roads/pavements repairs, blocking inappropriate development — cannot be delivered by him alone and will mostly fail against the ruling group's votes source
- + The Lib Dem winner of this post in May 2026 (Rob Turner) left the group and resigned within months, forcing this by-election; if Shaw also under-delivers on his 'work all year round' pledge, his voters will feel twice let down by the same party in the same seat source
- − Shaw has a highly visible local community profile (chair of Portchester Volunteer Marching Band, co-founder of Project 71) and campaigns on year-round casework; visible personal service is the classic mechanism by which ward councillors keep supporters saying they'd vote the same way source
- − His voters are largely habitual Lib Dem identifiers in a ward the Lib Dems won comfortably in May 2026 (1,050 votes, 54% turnout); partisan identity makes 'would you vote the same way again' a very low bar that most will clear regardless of his record source
- + The retrospective comes after the next contest (2-4 years away) in a competitive five-way field where Reform took 739 votes in May 2026; national tides and any major planning decision in the ward over that horizon could sour tactical and anti-development voters
Independent estimates: 11% regret / 84% would do it again — combined by averaging in log-odds.
Against this forecast: The strongest case the forecast is wrong is that 'would you vote the same way again' is an extremely low bar in a low-salience ward by-election: most of Shaw's voters are committed Lib Dems who will answer yes whatever he achieves, and any disappointment with roads or development will be blamed on the Conservative council majority rather than on one opposition backbencher — pushing regret as low as 3-5%. The mirror-image risk is that the Lib Dem seat churn (an elected Lib Dem quit within months) plus promises he structurally cannot keep could push regret toward 15-20% if a major development is approved or he goes quiet before the next contest.
Raw output from each forecasting pass
Pass 1:
{
"reference_class": "Voters asked after the fact whether they would vote the same way again in low-salience UK votes (2016 Brexit referendum repeat-vote polling: ~85-93% would repeat, so ~7-15% would not; general 'vote choice regret' surveys: ~2-13% explicit switchers), applied to a UK local council ward vote",
"base_rate": 0.1,
"mechanisms": [
{
"mechanism": "Shaw would join a small Lib Dem group (7 of 32 seats) on a Conservative-run council (22 seats), so his headline promises — roads/pavements repairs, blocking inappropriate development — cannot be delivered by him alone and will mostly fail against the ruling group's votes",
"direction": "increase",
"evidence": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_Fareham_Borough_Council_election"
},
{
"mechanism": "The Lib Dem winner of this post in May 2026 (Rob Turner) left the group and resigned within months, forcing this by-election; if Shaw also under-delivers on his 'work all year round' pledge, his voters will feel twice let down by the same party in the same seat",
"direction": "increase",
"evidence": "https://www.portsmouth.co.uk/news/politics/fareham-borough-council-by-election-as-portchester-wicor-rob-turner-resigns-9262735"
},
{
"mechanism": "Shaw has a highly visible local community profile (chair of Portchester Volunteer Marching Band, co-founder of Project 71) and campaigns on year-round casework; visible personal service is the classic mechanism by which ward councillors keep supporters saying they'd vote the same way",
"direction": "decrease",
"evidence": "https://www.dailyecho.co.uk/news/26660975.meet-candidates-battling-portchester-council-seat/"
},
{
"mechanism": "His voters are largely habitual Lib Dem identifiers in a ward the Lib Dems won comfortably in May 2026 (1,050 votes, 54% turnout); partisan identity makes 'would you vote the same way again' a very low bar that most will clear regardless of his record",
"direction": "decrease",
"evidence": "https://www.dailyecho.co.uk/news/26081430.fareham-borough-council-elections-2026-full-list-results/"
},
{
"mechanism": "The retrospective comes after the next contest (2-4 years away) in a competitive five-way field where Reform took 739 votes in May 2026; national tides and any major planning decision in the ward over that horizon could sour tactical and anti-development voters",
"direction": "increase",
"evidence": null
}
],
"counterargument": "The strongest case the forecast is wrong is that 'would you vote the same way again' is an extremely low bar in a low-salience ward by-election: most of Shaw's voters are committed Lib Dems who will answer yes whatever he achieves, and any disappointment with roads or development will be blamed on the Conservative council majority rather than on one opposition backbencher — pushing regret as low as 3-5%. The mirror-image risk is that the Lib Dem seat churn (an elected Lib Dem quit within months) plus promises he structurally cannot keep could push regret toward 15-20% if a major development is approved or he goes quiet before the next contest.",
"reasons": [
{
"reason": "Opposition impotence: roads and planning promises fail against the Conservative majority, disappointing delivery-focused voters",
"weight": 0.3
},
{
"reason": "Seat churn raises the bar: after the last Lib Dem quit within months, voters expect visible year-round work and notice if it doesn't come",
"weight": 0.2
},
{
"reason": "Tactical and anti-development voters see no change over the 2-4 year horizon and feel their vote achieved nothing",
"weight": 0.2
},
{
"reason": "National political tides shift over the term and sour some of his softer supporters",
"weight": 0.15
},
{
"reason": "Honeymoon fades as casework demands outstrip one backbencher's power and he is blamed for unkept local promises",
"weight": 0.15
}
],
"endorse_reasons": [
{
"reason": "Habitual Lib Dem identifiers in a Lib Dem-held ward simply repeat their vote when asked",
"weight": 0.35
},
{
"reason": "His visible community presence (marching band chair, Project 71 veterans work) sustains personal satisfaction among his voters",
"weight": 0.25
},
{
"reason": "Disappointment with council decisions is attributed to the Conservative ruling group, not to Shaw",
"weight": 0.25
},
{
"reason": "Low-salience local vote: few voters will tell a surveyor they'd change such a small-stakes choice",
"weight": 0.15
}
],
"regret_probability": 0.11,
"endorse_probability": 0.84
}We'll compare this with what voters say at the next election for this seat.
Earlier forecasts for this candidate
| Made | Regret forecast | Methodology |
|---|---|---|
| 2026-11-15 23:03:42 | 17% | regret-v2 |
| 2026-11-15 01:42:59 | 16% | regret-v1 |
Committed at 2026-11-16T12:01:04.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:622cfb22c4eada9f… · verify
What we could not verify
- The brief states the candidate 'did not win the previous contest' for this post (last contested 7 May 2026), but sources indicate the Liberal Democrat candidate in that contest was Rob Turner (who won), not Steve Shaw; no evidence was found that Steve Shaw stood in that election.
- No information found on campaign funding or donations.
- The by-election result is not yet available (polling day 19 November 2026).
- Democracy Club lists his age and gender as unknown, and no date of birth was found.
- Exact dates and details of his Royal Navy career, his events company role, and the founding date of Project 71 were not verified in the sources read.
Sources
Steve Shaw - Candidate for Portchester Wicor in Fareham local election (Democracy Club) · Steve Shaw for Portchester Wicor in the Fareham local election (Who Can I Vote For?) · Meet the candidates battling for Portchester council seat (Daily Echo) · Meet the five candidates battling for Portchester council seat (The News, Portsmouth) · Bollards proposed to prevent encampments at High View Park (Daily Echo) · Forthcoming By-Elections (ALDC) · Fareham Borough Council by-election to be held after Portchester Wicor councillor Rob Turner resigns (The News, Portsmouth) · Fareham Borough Council elections 2026: Full list of results (Daily Echo) · Project71 veterans and volunteers commemorate the 79th Anniversary of D-Day at St Mary's Church in Portchester (Your Thurrock) · Project71 veterans and volunteers commemorate D-Day anniversary in Portchester (The News, Portsmouth) · DWP Winter Fuel Payment cuts slammed by WW2 veteran group (Gazette News) · 'We must never forget': Poignant D-Day remembrance service honours veterans (The News, Portsmouth)