Portchester Wicor

Fareham local election · 2026-11-19 · candidates ordered by lowest predicted regret

Rob Turner (Liberal Democrats) won this seat on 2026-05-07.

Review their performance — did you vote last time?

Rob Turner was the Liberal Democrats' candidate for Portchester Wicor in the Fareham Borough Council election on 7 May 2026, which he won, before leaving the Liberal Democrat group and later resigning from the council during 2026.

Promises vs record: Turner was elected for the Liberal Democrats in Portchester Wicor on 7 May 2026 and said after leaving the party group in July 2026 that he remained "fully committed to representing the people of Portchester Wicor" and would continue attending council meetings and handling casework. He then resigned from the council entirely, with the vacancy formally declared on 1 October 2026, less than five months after his election, triggering a by-election on 19 November 2026.

Did you vote for Rob Turner in the previous election?

Why?

Your answers are compared with the regret forecasts made before the election.

Photo of Steve Shaw

Steve Shaw

Liberal Democrats

Who they are

Steve Shaw is a retired Royal Navy Commander who says he spent 40 years in the Royal Navy. He is a co-founder of Project 71, a not-for-profit organisation that supports Second World War veterans, and is chair of the Portchester Volunteer Marching Band. He describes Portchester as his home and is standing for the Liberal Democrats in the Portchester Wicor by-election to Fareham Borough Council on 19 November 2026. The by-election follows the resignation of Cllr Rob Turner, who was elected for the Liberal Democrats in May 2026 but left the party group in July 2026 citing health reasons and later resigned.

Retired Royal Navy Commander, Royal Navy, 40 years (specific dates not stated in sources) · Co-founder, Project 71 (not-for-profit supporting WW2 veterans), active by 2023–present · Chair, Portchester Volunteer Marching Band, 2026–present · Director, own events company (per Gazette report; dates not stated)

What they say

I'm proud to call Portchester my home and want to give something back to the community I care about. As a retired Royal Navy Commander with a strong background in community service, I know the importance of hard work, teamwork and getting things done. If elected, I'll work alongside local Liberal Democrat councillor Paul Nother to stand up for residents, protect our green spaces, challenge inappropriate development and make sure Portchester Wicor gets the attention it deserves. I'm asking for your vote on 19 November so I can work hard for Portchester all year round, not just at election time.
Statement to voters: "I'm proud to call Portchester my home and want to give something back to the community I care about. As a retired Royal Navy Commander with a strong background in community service, I know the importance of hard work, teamwork and getting things done. If elected, I'll work alongside local Liberal Democrat councillor Paul Nother to stand up for residents, protect our green spaces, challenge inappropriate development and make sure Portchester Wicor gets the attention it deserves. I'm asking for your vote on 19 November so I can work hard for Portchester all year round, not just at election time."
2026-10-18 · source
Said he wants to continue serving his community after spending 40 years in the Royal Navy, and that supporting veterans is particularly important to him alongside everyday issues affecting residents.
source
Stated his priorities include getting roads and pavements repaired, protecting green spaces and supporting charities and community groups, and said he wants to be a councillor who listens to residents and works throughout the year.
source
Backed a Liberal Democrat proposal to install bollards at High View Park to prevent unauthorised encampments, calling it "common sense".
source
As co-founder of Project 71, spoke about supporting WW2 veterans, including warning that Winter Fuel Payment cuts would force some veterans to choose between "eating and heating".
source

What they promise

Regret forecast forecast — a projection, not a reported fact

Why voters for Steve Shaw might regret it:

Why they might not regret it:

The reasoning

Starting point: 10% base rate of regret for Voters asked after the fact whether they would vote the same way again in low-salience UK votes (2016 Brexit referendum repeat-vote polling: ~85-93% would repeat, so ~7-15% would not; general 'vote choice regret' surveys: ~2-13% explicit switchers), applied to a UK local council ward vote, then adjusted for this candidate.

Independent estimates: 11% regret / 84% would do it again — combined by averaging in log-odds.

Against this forecast: The strongest case the forecast is wrong is that 'would you vote the same way again' is an extremely low bar in a low-salience ward by-election: most of Shaw's voters are committed Lib Dems who will answer yes whatever he achieves, and any disappointment with roads or development will be blamed on the Conservative council majority rather than on one opposition backbencher — pushing regret as low as 3-5%. The mirror-image risk is that the Lib Dem seat churn (an elected Lib Dem quit within months) plus promises he structurally cannot keep could push regret toward 15-20% if a major development is approved or he goes quiet before the next contest.

Raw output from each forecasting pass

Pass 1:

{
  "reference_class": "Voters asked after the fact whether they would vote the same way again in low-salience UK votes (2016 Brexit referendum repeat-vote polling: ~85-93% would repeat, so ~7-15% would not; general 'vote choice regret' surveys: ~2-13% explicit switchers), applied to a UK local council ward vote",
  "base_rate": 0.1,
  "mechanisms": [
    {
      "mechanism": "Shaw would join a small Lib Dem group (7 of 32 seats) on a Conservative-run council (22 seats), so his headline promises — roads/pavements repairs, blocking inappropriate development — cannot be delivered by him alone and will mostly fail against the ruling group's votes",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_Fareham_Borough_Council_election"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "The Lib Dem winner of this post in May 2026 (Rob Turner) left the group and resigned within months, forcing this by-election; if Shaw also under-delivers on his 'work all year round' pledge, his voters will feel twice let down by the same party in the same seat",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://www.portsmouth.co.uk/news/politics/fareham-borough-council-by-election-as-portchester-wicor-rob-turner-resigns-9262735"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "Shaw has a highly visible local community profile (chair of Portchester Volunteer Marching Band, co-founder of Project 71) and campaigns on year-round casework; visible personal service is the classic mechanism by which ward councillors keep supporters saying they'd vote the same way",
      "direction": "decrease",
      "evidence": "https://www.dailyecho.co.uk/news/26660975.meet-candidates-battling-portchester-council-seat/"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "His voters are largely habitual Lib Dem identifiers in a ward the Lib Dems won comfortably in May 2026 (1,050 votes, 54% turnout); partisan identity makes 'would you vote the same way again' a very low bar that most will clear regardless of his record",
      "direction": "decrease",
      "evidence": "https://www.dailyecho.co.uk/news/26081430.fareham-borough-council-elections-2026-full-list-results/"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "The retrospective comes after the next contest (2-4 years away) in a competitive five-way field where Reform took 739 votes in May 2026; national tides and any major planning decision in the ward over that horizon could sour tactical and anti-development voters",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": null
    }
  ],
  "counterargument": "The strongest case the forecast is wrong is that 'would you vote the same way again' is an extremely low bar in a low-salience ward by-election: most of Shaw's voters are committed Lib Dems who will answer yes whatever he achieves, and any disappointment with roads or development will be blamed on the Conservative council majority rather than on one opposition backbencher — pushing regret as low as 3-5%. The mirror-image risk is that the Lib Dem seat churn (an elected Lib Dem quit within months) plus promises he structurally cannot keep could push regret toward 15-20% if a major development is approved or he goes quiet before the next contest.",
  "reasons": [
    {
      "reason": "Opposition impotence: roads and planning promises fail against the Conservative majority, disappointing delivery-focused voters",
      "weight": 0.3
    },
    {
      "reason": "Seat churn raises the bar: after the last Lib Dem quit within months, voters expect visible year-round work and notice if it doesn't come",
      "weight": 0.2
    },
    {
      "reason": "Tactical and anti-development voters see no change over the 2-4 year horizon and feel their vote achieved nothing",
      "weight": 0.2
    },
    {
      "reason": "National political tides shift over the term and sour some of his softer supporters",
      "weight": 0.15
    },
    {
      "reason": "Honeymoon fades as casework demands outstrip one backbencher's power and he is blamed for unkept local promises",
      "weight": 0.15
    }
  ],
  "endorse_reasons": [
    {
      "reason": "Habitual Lib Dem identifiers in a Lib Dem-held ward simply repeat their vote when asked",
      "weight": 0.35
    },
    {
      "reason": "His visible community presence (marching band chair, Project 71 veterans work) sustains personal satisfaction among his voters",
      "weight": 0.25
    },
    {
      "reason": "Disappointment with council decisions is attributed to the Conservative ruling group, not to Shaw",
      "weight": 0.25
    },
    {
      "reason": "Low-salience local vote: few voters will tell a surveyor they'd change such a small-stakes choice",
      "weight": 0.15
    }
  ],
  "regret_probability": 0.11,
  "endorse_probability": 0.84
}

We'll compare this with what voters say at the next election for this seat.

Earlier forecasts for this candidate
MadeRegret forecastMethodology
2026-11-15 23:03:4217%regret-v2
2026-11-15 01:42:5916%regret-v1

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:01:04.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:622cfb22c4eada9f… · verify

What we could not verify

Sources

Steve Shaw - Candidate for Portchester Wicor in Fareham local election (Democracy Club) · Steve Shaw for Portchester Wicor in the Fareham local election (Who Can I Vote For?) · Meet the candidates battling for Portchester council seat (Daily Echo) · Meet the five candidates battling for Portchester council seat (The News, Portsmouth) · Bollards proposed to prevent encampments at High View Park (Daily Echo) · Forthcoming By-Elections (ALDC) · Fareham Borough Council by-election to be held after Portchester Wicor councillor Rob Turner resigns (The News, Portsmouth) · Fareham Borough Council elections 2026: Full list of results (Daily Echo) · Project71 veterans and volunteers commemorate the 79th Anniversary of D-Day at St Mary's Church in Portchester (Your Thurrock) · Project71 veterans and volunteers commemorate D-Day anniversary in Portchester (The News, Portsmouth) · DWP Winter Fuel Payment cuts slammed by WW2 veteran group (Gazette News) · 'We must never forget': Poignant D-Day remembrance service honours veterans (The News, Portsmouth)

Photo of Paul Kimber

Paul Kimber

Reform UK

Who they are

Paul Kimber is standing for Reform UK in the Portchester Wicor by-election on 19 November 2026. In his statement to voters he says he is not a career politician, left school at 16 and has worked as a bus driver, driving instructor and delivery driver, later building his own business. He says his wife runs a business on West Street in Portchester and his daughter lives in the ward. He previously stood for Reform UK in the Avenue ward at the Fareham Borough Council election on 7 May 2026, where he came second with 957 votes (31.4%) behind the Conservative candidate, in a contest the Conservatives held. The Portchester Wicor by-election was triggered by the resignation of independent councillor Rob Turner, who had been elected as a Liberal Democrat in May 2026 and stepped down in autumn 2026.

Reform UK candidate, Portchester Wicor by-election, Fareham Borough Council, 2026 · Reform UK candidate, Avenue ward, Fareham Borough Council election, 2026 (not elected; 957 votes, 2nd of 5)

What they say

My name is Paul Kimber and I’m standing as your Reform UK candidate in the upcoming by-election for Portchester Wicor on Thursday 19th November. I’m not a career politician. I left school at 16 and have worked as a bus driver, driving instructor and delivery driver. I’ve lived in council housing, rented accommodation and eventually became the proud owner of a mortgage! I know what it means to work long hours, worry about bills and support a family. It is those experiences that helped me build my own business over ten years ago - built on respect and listening to people. My wife runs her own business on West Street and my daughter lives in the ward and plans to raise a family here, so Portchester matters to me personally. I want to be a councillor you can actually reach. I’ll publish my telephone number, share updates through an information-only WhatsApp group and my Community Engagement Facebook page and let you know where I’ll be available for a chat each week. If you can’t get out, I’m happy to visit you at home. I won’t promise the earth (stopping your neighbour’s cat from using your garden as a toilet might be beyond me!) but if I can help, I will but If I can’t, I will find someone who can. I’m already actively involved in: Supporting Suella Braverman’s campaign for a banking hub in Portchester precinct. Meeting residents opposing the HA52 development off Dore Avenue. Raising speeding concerns on West Street, White Hart Lane and The Crossway with Reform’s Hampshire County Councillors. Exploring options for a new pedestrian crossing on West Street near Westland Grove. I want council taxpayers’ money spent wisely on things that matter to Portchester residents. I’ll ask questions, challenge decisions and press for local improvements rather than accepting a simple “there’s no money” answer. I’m afraid that answer won’t work for me and it doesn’t work for you, either. Let’s stop wasting money on vanity projects and use it where it matters - such as road safety, improved street lighting, as well as reducing crime and antisocial behaviour. We need Portchester to be a place where residents feel safe day and night! I won’t have all the answers but I’ll listen, be honest and act as a strong local champion for you on Fareham Borough Council.
Statement to voters: "I'm not a career politician. I left school at 16 and have worked as a bus driver, driving instructor and delivery driver."
2026-10-28 · source
Statement to voters: "My wife runs her own business on West Street and my daughter lives in the ward and plans to raise a family here, so Portchester matters to me personally."
2026-10-28 · source
Says he is "already actively involved" in "Supporting Suella Braverman's campaign for a banking hub in Portchester precinct".
2026-10-28 · source
Says he is "already actively involved" in "Meeting residents opposing the HA52 development off Dore Avenue".
2026-10-28 · source
Says he is "already actively involved" in "Raising speeding concerns on West Street, White Hart Lane and The Crossway with Reform's Hampshire County Councillors".
2026-10-28 · source
Says he is "already actively involved" in "Exploring options for a new pedestrian crossing on West Street near Westland Grove".
2026-10-28 · source
Reported as saying his family has strong connections to Portchester, with his wife running a business on West Street and his daughter living in the ward; a business owner with a background in transport and driver training, he wants to tackle speeding, crime and anti-social behaviour and protect the area from inappropriate development.
source
Reported as highlighting road safety on West Street, White Hart Lane and The Crossway, proposals for development off Dore Avenue, and efforts to secure a banking hub.
source
May 2026 Avenue ward profile: "I have lived locally in Stubbington, Titchfield and now Fareham for the past 11 years, and I care deeply about our community and the issues that affect residents every day."
source
May 2026 Avenue ward profile: "I am standing for Reform UK because I believe that local people deserve better representation, more transparency, and real value for money."
source
May 2026 Avenue ward profile: "I am currently supporting our candidate for Fareham Park in opposing the proposed closure of Henry Cort School, which I believe has a vital role to play in supporting the broader Fareham community, particularly those with special educational needs."
source

What they promise

Regret forecast forecast — a projection, not a reported fact

Why voters for Paul Kimber might regret it:

Why they might not regret it:

The reasoning

Starting point: 10% base rate of regret for UK voters asked after a national or local contest whether they would vote the same way again (Brexit referendum switchers, 2024 general election regret polls), plus voters of volatile minor-party/protest candidates in low-salience local contests, then adjusted for this candidate.

Independent estimates: 13% regret / 82% would do it again — combined by averaging in log-odds.

Against this forecast: The strongest case that regret is much lower is that 'would you vote the same way again' polling almost always shows large majorities sticking with their choice (85-93% for Brexit, ~87-98% for 2024 votes), and by-election Reform voters are among the most committed, low-expectation partisans in the electorate: Kimber explicitly promises little beyond being reachable, he is in opposition so he cannot be blamed for council failures, and even a defection to independent may faze few local voters who cared mainly about the HA52 development and speeding. On this view regret stays in the low single digits and endorsement exceeds 90%.

Raw output from each forecasting pass

Pass 1:

{
  "reference_class": "UK voters asked after a national or local contest whether they would vote the same way again (Brexit referendum switchers, 2024 general election regret polls), plus voters of volatile minor-party/protest candidates in low-salience local contests",
  "base_rate": 0.1,
  "mechanisms": [
    {
      "mechanism": "If elected, Kimber joins a party with an extraordinary councillor attrition rate: 120+ Reform councillors elected in May 2026 have already resigned, defected, been suspended or expelled within about six months (defections to independents/Conservatives/Restore, resignations after scandals including the ITV undercover expose). If he defects, resigns or is suspended before the next contest, his voters will feel abandoned and many will say they would not vote the same way again.",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://www.markpack.org.uk/176783/how-many-councillors-has-reform-uk-lost-since-the-may-2026-elections/"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "Reform's national brand is eroding over the term: the party led on 26-27% at the May 2026 locals but has fallen to about 21% by November 2026, with Farage's net approval deeply negative (-15 to -37). Some of his voters will sour on the party they backed and defect at the retrospective.",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://britpolls.co.uk/"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "His headline local goals (banking hub, pedestrian crossing on West Street, blocking the HA52 development, speeding enforcement) all depend on a Conservative-run Fareham council and Hampshire County Council, so a lone Reform councillor in opposition may deliver little on the issues that motivated a chunk of his voters.",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://www.dailyecho.co.uk/news/26660975.meet-candidates-battling-portchester-council-seat/"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "His platform is deliberately modest and his accessibility promises (published phone number, WhatsApp updates, weekly surgeries, home visits) are fully within his personal control, so he can visibly keep his word and keep disappointment low.",
      "direction": "decrease",
      "evidence": "https://candidates.democracyclub.org.uk/person/128600/"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "The ward's previous councillor (Rob Turner) was elected as a Lib Dem, defected to independent and resigned, triggering this by-election; local voters are primed to punish a councillor who changes colours or quits, amplifying regret in any defection scenario.",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://www.portsmouth.co.uk/news/politics/fareham-borough-council-by-election-as-portchester-wicor-rob-turner-resigns-9262735"
    }
  ],
  "counterargument": "The strongest case that regret is much lower is that 'would you vote the same way again' polling almost always shows large majorities sticking with their choice (85-93% for Brexit, ~87-98% for 2024 votes), and by-election Reform voters are among the most committed, low-expectation partisans in the electorate: Kimber explicitly promises little beyond being reachable, he is in opposition so he cannot be blamed for council failures, and even a defection to independent may faze few local voters who cared mainly about the HA52 development and speeding. On this view regret stays in the low single digits and endorsement exceeds 90%.",
  "reasons": [
    {
      "reason": "Reform councillor churn: with 120+ Reform councillors gone within six months, Kimber may defect, resign or be suspended, leaving his voters feeling the vote was wasted",
      "weight": 0.35
    },
    {
      "reason": "Party brand erosion: Reform has slid from 26-27% to ~21% and Farage's approval is deeply negative, so soft supporters sour on their choice",
      "weight": 0.25
    },
    {
      "reason": "Unmet local deliverables: banking hub, crossing and blocking HA52 depend on a Tory-run council, so headline issues may go nowhere",
      "weight": 0.2
    },
    {
      "reason": "Protest-voter drift: soft anti-development and disaffected voters who backed him protest-style revert to Lib Dem or Con at the next contest",
      "weight": 0.1
    },
    {
      "reason": "Ward defection sensitivity: predecessor Rob Turner defected and quit, priming these voters to punish a councillor who changes colours",
      "weight": 0.1
    }
  ],
  "endorse_reasons": [
    {
      "reason": "Deliverable accessibility: published phone number, WhatsApp updates and home visits are within his control and visibly kept",
      "weight": 0.3
    },
    {
      "reason": "Committed partisan base: by-election Reform voters are loyal identifiers who overwhelmingly say they would vote the same way again",
      "weight": 0.3
    },
    {
      "reason": "Effective opposition role: as a lone councillor he claims credit for scrutiny on speeding, lighting and crime without owning council failures",
      "weight": 0.2
    },
    {
      "reason": "Deep local roots: family business on West Street and family in the ward keep him engaged and visible to his voters",
      "weight": 0.2
    }
  ],
  "regret_probability": 0.13,
  "endorse_probability": 0.82
}

We'll compare this with what voters say at the next election for this seat.

Earlier forecasts for this candidate
MadeRegret forecastMethodology
2026-11-15 22:55:1522%regret-v2
2026-11-15 01:42:2722%regret-v1

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:01:02.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:70cc3def7b651dbc… · verify

What we could not verify

Sources

Paul Kimber - Candidate for Portchester Wicor in Fareham local election | Democracy Club · Meet the candidates battling for Portchester council seat | Daily Echo · Meet the five candidates battling for Portchester council seat | The News (Portsmouth) · Election 2026: All the candidates standing for Fareham Borough Council in the 2026 election | The News (Portsmouth) · Fareham Borough Council elections 2026: Full list of results | Daily Echo · Local elections 2026: Fareham Borough Council results | The News (Portsmouth) · 2026 Fareham Borough Council election | Wikipedia · Fareham Borough Council by-election to be held after Portchester Wicor councillor Rob Turner resigns | The News (Portsmouth) · Forthcoming By-Elections | ALDC

Photo of George William Ponsford

George William Ponsford

Restore Britain

Who they are

George William Ponsford is standing for Restore Britain in the Portchester Wicor by-election to Fareham Borough Council on 19 November 2026. Published candidate profiles are brief: he is quoted as saying he "takes pride in helping others overcome challenges, offering advice, support and effective solutions," that he values time with his son, and that he believes "restoring a British way of life and our culture" is important. No verified details of his occupation, residence or prior public roles were found in the sources reviewed. Restore Britain is a party founded by Rupert Lowe, launched as a pressure group in June 2025 and registered as a political party in February 2026, described in Wikipedia as ethno-nationalist and far-right.

Said he "takes pride in helping others overcome challenges, offering advice, support and effective solutions."
2026-11-03 · source
Said he values time with his son.
2026-11-03 · source
Said he believes "restoring a British way of life and our culture" is important.
2026-11-03 · source

What they promise

Regret forecast forecast — a projection, not a reported fact

Why voters for George William Ponsford might regret it:

Why they might not regret it:

The reasoning

Starting point: 12% base rate of regret for Retrospective 'would you vote the same way again' polls of UK voters in low-salience, expressive votes for minor or protest parties (Brexit study: ~85-93% of Leave/Remain voters would repeat, i.e. ~7-15% regret; US 2024 'would vote differently' polls: 2-13%), then adjusted for this candidate.

Independent estimates: 16% regret / 78% would do it again — combined by averaging in log-odds.

Against this forecast: The strongest case the forecast is wrong is downward: 'would you vote the same way again' questions almost always show 85-95% stickiness, and a Ponsford win would be such a stunning result for a fringe party that his voters would feel pride rather than regret; delivery expectations for one opposition councillor are near zero, so there is little to be disappointed by. The strongest upward case is that a brand-new, thinly vetted party with a track record of defections produces a scandal, inactivity, or a party collapse before May 2028, pushing regret toward 25%+.

Raw output from each forecasting pass

Pass 1:

{
  "reference_class": "Retrospective 'would you vote the same way again' polls of UK voters in low-salience, expressive votes for minor or protest parties (Brexit study: ~85-93% of Leave/Remain voters would repeat, i.e. ~7-15% regret; US 2024 'would vote differently' polls: 2-13%)",
  "base_rate": 0.12,
  "mechanisms": [
    {
      "mechanism": "If elected, Ponsford would be a lone Restore Britain councillor with no group on a Conservative-run council (22 of 32 seats), with almost no power to deliver on 'restoring a British way of life' or even local change, so some voters expecting visible results will feel let down by the May 2028 retrospective",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/election/2026/england/councils/E07000087"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "Restore Britain is a party registered only in Feb 2026 with an established pattern of councillor instability (defections to and from Reform within days); if Ponsford defects, falls out with the party, or the party implodes/merges before the next contest, his voters may say they would not vote the same way again",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c3rz0jv9r2po"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "Thin candidate vetting by a new party (no verified biography, no campaign platform located) raises the chance that adverse information or poor councillor performance emerges after election, souring his voters",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": null
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "Portchester Wicor is a three-way marginal (May 2026: LD 858, Reform 788, Con 765); if Ponsford wins he likely collects lent tactical votes from Con/Reform backers blocking the Lib Dems, and lent voters are the most likely to say they would vote differently in hindsight",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://www.portsmouth.co.uk/news/politics/local-elections-2026-fareham-borough-council-results-8506148"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "Winning would be a historic upset for a party whose by-election vote shares usually run 4-11%; his voters would feel their protest vote achieved something extraordinary, and expressive protest voters show very high retrospective stickiness (only ~5-10% of such voters say they would switch)",
      "direction": "decrease",
      "evidence": "https://restore-britain-tracker.netlify.app/"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "His voters are motivated culture-war/anti-establishment voters with low delivery expectations for a single borough councillor; comparable ideological voters (Brexit Leavers ~85-90%, Trump 2024 voters ~90%+) overwhelmingly say they would vote the same way again",
      "direction": "decrease",
      "evidence": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11127-022-00997-z"
    }
  ],
  "counterargument": "The strongest case the forecast is wrong is downward: 'would you vote the same way again' questions almost always show 85-95% stickiness, and a Ponsford win would be such a stunning result for a fringe party that his voters would feel pride rather than regret; delivery expectations for one opposition councillor are near zero, so there is little to be disappointed by. The strongest upward case is that a brand-new, thinly vetted party with a track record of defections produces a scandal, inactivity, or a party collapse before May 2028, pushing regret toward 25%+.",
  "reasons": [
    {
      "reason": "Lone councillor on a Conservative-run council cannot deliver visible change, disappointing voters expecting results",
      "weight": 0.3
    },
    {
      "reason": "Party instability and defection risk before the May 2028 contest leaves voters feeling their vote was wasted",
      "weight": 0.25
    },
    {
      "reason": "Lent tactical voters in a three-way marginal revert and say they would vote differently",
      "weight": 0.25
    },
    {
      "reason": "Thin vetting of a new party's candidate raises the chance of post-election scandal or poor performance",
      "weight": 0.2
    }
  ],
  "endorse_reasons": [
    {
      "reason": "A historic upset win makes his voters proud that their protest vote counted",
      "weight": 0.35
    },
    {
      "reason": "Motivated ideological and anti-establishment voters show very high retrospective stickiness",
      "weight": 0.35
    },
    {
      "reason": "Low expectations for a single backbench councillor leave little scope for disappointment",
      "weight": 0.3
    }
  ],
  "regret_probability": 0.16,
  "endorse_probability": 0.78
}

We'll compare this with what voters say at the next election for this seat.

Earlier forecasts for this candidate
MadeRegret forecastMethodology
2026-11-15 20:16:4821%regret-v2
2026-11-15 01:40:4725%regret-v1

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:01:03.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:4c834d0b41be3ab8… · verify

What we could not verify

Sources

Meet the candidates battling for Portchester council seat - Daily Echo · Meet the five candidates battling for Portchester council seat - The News, Portsmouth · George William Ponsford - Democracy Club candidate record · George William Ponsford for Portchester Wicor - Who Can I Vote For? · Restore Britain Electoral Performance Tracker · Restore Britain - Wikipedia · 2026 Fareham Borough Council election - Wikipedia · Fareham Borough Council by-election to be held after Portchester Wicor councillor Rob Turner resigns - The News, Portsmouth · Forthcoming By-Elections - ALDC

Photo of Harry Patrick Davis

Harry Patrick Davis

Conservative and Unionist Party

Who they are

Harry Patrick Davis is a Conservative and Unionist Party candidate standing in the Portchester Wicor by-election for Fareham Borough Council on 19 November 2026. He lives in Portchester and was first involved in local politics as a teenager, launching an 'Action for Portchester' campaign and contesting Portchester East in the May 2022 borough elections, where he was not elected (1,205 votes, third of seven candidates). He was elected as a borough councillor for Portchester East at the by-election on 20 October 2022 with 957 votes (37.6%), a Conservative gain from the Liberal Democrats, and was reported at the time as being 18 years old and the youngest person ever to stand for the Conservatives in Fareham; he was welcomed to his first full council meeting on 27 October 2022 and appointed a trustee of the Portchester Parish Hall Board of Trustees for the remainder of 2022/23. After boundary changes created new wards, he stood in Wallington & Downend at the all-out election on 2 May 2024 and was not elected (815 votes, 20%, with both seats won by the Liberal Democrats), ending his term on the borough council. He did not contest the May 2026 Portchester Wicor election and is now standing in the November 2026 by-election caused by the resignation of Liberal Democrat councillor Rob Turner. His stated 2026 priorities are investment in Portchester precinct, improvements to Wicor Recreation Ground, action on speeding and noisy exhausts, reinstating the Dore Avenue bus service and addressing the area's 'crumbling coastline'.

Borough Councillor, Fareham Borough Council (Portchester East ward), October 2022 – May 2024 · Trustee, Portchester Parish Hall Board of Trustees, 2022–2023 · Conservative candidate, Portchester East, Fareham Borough Council election, May 2022 (not elected) · Conservative candidate, Wallington & Downend, Fareham Borough Council election, May 2024 (not elected) · Conservative candidate, Portchester Wicor, Fareham Borough Council by-election, November 2026

What they say

Harry has a proven record of working hard for Portchester all-year-round. He already has experience fighting for our area on Fareham Council: his voice is listened to and gets results! Harry lives in Portchester. He's a keen hiker, charity fundraiser, and effective local campaigner... just the kind of hard-working Councillor we need to stand up for Portchester on the Council.
He said his priorities include investment in the precinct, improvements to Wicor Recreation Ground and action on speeding and noisy exhausts.
2026-11-03 · source
He said he would campaign to reinstate the Dore Avenue bus service and tackle the area's 'crumbling coastline'.
2026-11-03 · source
He said he opposed any plans to merge Portchester with Portsmouth City Council and argued the area deserved a councillor who would provide long-term representation.
2026-11-03 · source
'I am very enthusiastic and passionate about my hometown of Portchester and want to work with all councillors from any party to make our village an even better place.'
2022-04-13 · source
'I am in the process of discussing the possibility of setting up a "Youth Council" where young people can make their views properly heard.'
2022-04-13 · source
'Harry has a proven record of working hard for Portchester all-year-round. He already has experience fighting for our area on Fareham Council: his voice is listened to and gets results!' (candidate statement to voters)
2026-10-30 · source

What they promise

Regret forecast forecast — a projection, not a reported fact

Why voters for Harry Patrick Davis might regret it:

Why they might not regret it:

The reasoning

Starting point: 15% base rate of regret for UK voters in low-salience local council elections and by-elections, calibrated against retrospective 'voted the wrong way / would vote the same way again' polling (Savanta 2026: 23% of all 2024 GE voters regretted their vote, 14% of Conservative voters; Brexit referendum studies: ~5-10% of voters would vote differently), then adjusted for this candidate.

Independent estimates: 16% regret / 76% would do it again — combined by averaging in log-odds.

Against this forecast: The strongest case for a much lower figure (~8-10%) is that by-election voters are the most partisan, habitual segment of the electorate, retrospective 'would you vote the same way' stickiness is typically 85-95% even for national votes, the Fareham Conservative brand is locally resilient, and Davis is a diligent, visible local campaigner whose supporters credit effort and blame the Lib Dem-run opposition or external actors (bus operators, coastal funding) for non-delivery. The strongest case for a much higher figure (~25-30%) is that he wins narrowly on borrowed votes in a ward that voted Lib Dem six months earlier, his marquee promises are structurally undeliverable by one councillor, and the national Tory brand could deteriorate further against Reform by 2028.

Raw output from each forecasting pass

Pass 1:

{
  "reference_class": "UK voters in low-salience local council elections and by-elections, calibrated against retrospective 'voted the wrong way / would vote the same way again' polling (Savanta 2026: 23% of all 2024 GE voters regretted their vote, 14% of Conservative voters; Brexit referendum studies: ~5-10% of voters would vote differently)",
  "base_rate": 0.15,
  "mechanisms": [
    {
      "mechanism": "His headline promises — reinstating the Dore Avenue bus service (a commercial/Hampshire County Council matter), tackling the 'crumbling coastline' (long-term coastal defence funding) and precinct investment — are largely outside one backbench councillor's control and cannot visibly be delivered before the next contest (~18 months), so promise-led supporters will feel let down",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://www.dailyecho.co.uk/news/26660975.meet-candidates-battling-portchester-council-seat/"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "A five-way race (Con, LD, Reform, Labour, Restore Britain) in a ward the Liberal Democrats won in May 2026 means a Davis win would likely be narrow and depend on borrowed Reform/tactical anti-LD votes; borrowed voters are the most likely to defect and say they would not vote the same way again",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://www.portsmouth.co.uk/news/politics/fareham-borough-council-by-election-as-portchester-wicor-rob-turner-resigns-9262735"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "The national Conservative brand is at a low ebb (563 councillors lost in May 2026) with Reform UK surging; if that flux continues to 2028, some of his voters drift to Reform or the Lib Dems and repudiate their by-election vote",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/election/2026/england/councils/E07000087"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "Local election electorates are small, habitual and partisan; Fareham Conservatives proved electorally resilient (39% of the vote, 22 seats held in 2026) and Davis is a known local figure with prior council service, so most of his voters are committed partisans who will stick",
      "direction": "decrease",
      "evidence": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_Fareham_Borough_Council_election"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "Davis campaigns on visible year-round local casework (Action for Portchester, speeding, precinct); personal service credit sustains support even when headline promises stall, and the short horizon to the next contest limits the window for disappointment",
      "direction": "decrease",
      "evidence": "https://www.fwca.org.uk/people/harry-davis"
    }
  ],
  "counterargument": "The strongest case for a much lower figure (~8-10%) is that by-election voters are the most partisan, habitual segment of the electorate, retrospective 'would you vote the same way' stickiness is typically 85-95% even for national votes, the Fareham Conservative brand is locally resilient, and Davis is a diligent, visible local campaigner whose supporters credit effort and blame the Lib Dem-run opposition or external actors (bus operators, coastal funding) for non-delivery. The strongest case for a much higher figure (~25-30%) is that he wins narrowly on borrowed votes in a ward that voted Lib Dem six months earlier, his marquee promises are structurally undeliverable by one councillor, and the national Tory brand could deteriorate further against Reform by 2028.",
  "reasons": [
    {
      "reason": "Bus service, coastline and precinct promises cannot be delivered by one councillor before the next contest, disappointing promise-led voters",
      "weight": 0.3
    },
    {
      "reason": "Narrow five-way win would rest on borrowed Reform/tactical votes that return home and regret",
      "weight": 0.25
    },
    {
      "reason": "Continued national Conservative weakness and Reform surge pulls his voters away by 2028",
      "weight": 0.2
    },
    {
      "reason": "'Gets results' claim is thin (lost re-election in 2024, no verified delivery record), so expectations outrun what he achieves",
      "weight": 0.15
    },
    {
      "reason": "Low-salience by-election supporters with weak personal attachment drift within 18 months",
      "weight": 0.1
    }
  ],
  "endorse_reasons": [
    {
      "reason": "Habitual partisan local voters overwhelmingly say they would vote the same way again",
      "weight": 0.3
    },
    {
      "reason": "Visible year-round casework on speeding, precinct and recreation ground builds personal loyalty",
      "weight": 0.25
    },
    {
      "reason": "Fareham Conservatives' resilient local brand (22 seats held in 2026) keeps his voters in the fold",
      "weight": 0.2
    },
    {
      "reason": "Short ~18-month horizon to the next contest leaves little time for disillusionment",
      "weight": 0.15
    },
    {
      "reason": "Voters credit visible effort and blame external bodies for stalled projects",
      "weight": 0.1
    }
  ],
  "regret_probability": 0.16,
  "endorse_probability": 0.76
}

We'll compare this with what voters say at the next election for this seat.

Earlier forecasts for this candidate
MadeRegret forecastMethodology
2026-11-15 19:04:3120%regret-v2
2026-11-15 01:41:1121%regret-v1

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:01:03.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:79b4c79b56868923… · verify

What we could not verify

Sources

Meet the candidates battling for Portchester council seat (Daily Echo) · Meet the five candidates battling for Portchester council seat (Portsmouth News) · Harry Patrick Davis - Candidate for Portchester Wicor in Fareham local election (Democracy Club) · Harry Davis (Fareham & Waterlooville Conservatives) · 2024 Fareham Borough Council election (Wikipedia) · Fareham Borough Council elections - by-election results (Wikipedia) · Election results for Wallington & Downend, 2 May 2024 (Fareham Borough Council) · Agenda and minutes, Council, Thursday 27 October 2022 (Fareham Borough Council) · The 'enthusiastic and passionate' Tory teenager standing for election in Fareham (HampshireLive) · Fareham Local Election candidates 2022 (HampshireLive) · Portchester East by-election - meet the candidates (Portsmouth News) · Fareham Borough Council by-election to be held after Portchester Wicor councillor Rob Turner resigns (Portsmouth News) · Local elections 2026: Fareham Borough Council results (Portsmouth News) · Full list of Fareham local election results as Conservatives hold (Portsmouth News) · Councillors attendance summary, 27 March 2024 - 19 September 2024 (Fareham Borough Council)

Photo of Lorraine Drinkwater

Lorraine Drinkwater

Labour Party

Who they are

Lorraine Drinkwater has lived in Portchester for more than 20 years. She is chair of governors at a local school and describes herself as a former foster carer and church warden, and says she already helps the community through the Warm Hub and a School Uniform Exchange. She has previously stood for Labour in the Titchfield area, contesting both the Fareham Borough Council election and the Hampshire County Council election on 7 May 2026, and was not elected in either. She is standing in the Portchester Wicor by-election on 19 November 2026, caused by the resignation of a councillor who had been elected as a Liberal Democrat and later sat as an independent.

Labour Party candidate, Portchester Wicor ward, Fareham Borough Council by-election, 2026 · Chair of governors, a local school, years not specified · Former foster carer, years not specified · Former church warden, years not specified · Candidate (not elected), Hampshire County Council, Fareham Titchfield division, 2026 · Candidate (not elected), Fareham Borough Council, Titchfield ward, 2026

What they say

Portchester has been my home for over 20 years. I’m Chair of Governors at a local school, a former foster carer and church warden, and I already help our community through the Warm Hub and School Uniform Exchange. I’m standing because I want to get stuck into the issues residents keep raising and make sure Portchester has a councillor who will keep pushing until something is done. My priorities are clear: 1) Get Portchester Precinct moving — push for the improvements residents have waited years for and a better mix of shops and services, rather than simply more vape shops and barbers. 2) Keep Precinct parking free. I opposed the parking charges at Wicor Rec and will fight any attempt to introduce charges at the Precinct. 3) Create a proper youth space in Portchester, giving young people somewhere safe to go. 4) Bring the School Uniform Exchange to Portchester to help families with the cost of school clothing. 5) Tackle speeding and noisy driving, including pushing for a noise-camera trial on the A27 and other problem roads. 6) Protect our shoreline, pushing for the sea defences needed to tackle erosion and stop historic landfill entering the harbour. 7) Get tougher on fly-tipping, litter and dog mess and keep chasing the everyday problems that make neighbourhoods feel neglected. I’ll work cross-party whenever that gets something done, but I won’t be afraid to challenge the Council when Portchester is being ignored.
Portchester has been my home for over 20 years.
2026-10-14 · source
I'm Chair of Governors at a local school, a former foster carer and church warden, and I already help our community through the Warm Hub and School Uniform Exchange.
2026-10-14 · source
I'm standing because I want to get stuck into the issues residents keep raising and make sure Portchester has a councillor who will keep pushing until something is done.
2026-10-14 · source
I opposed the parking charges at Wicor Rec and will fight any attempt to introduce charges at the Precinct.
2026-10-14 · source
She said she was standing because Portchester needed stronger voices willing to challenge those in charge.
source
Labour candidate Lorraine Drinkwater has lived in Portchester for more than 20 years and is chair of governors at a school, as well as a former foster carer and church warden.
2026-11-03 · source

What they promise

Regret forecast forecast — a projection, not a reported fact

Why voters for Lorraine Drinkwater might regret it:

Why they might not regret it:

The reasoning

Starting point: 18% base rate of regret for Retrospective 'would you vote the same way again' polls after national and local votes (post-election surveys of recent voters): typically 72-85% say they would vote the same way again, with explicit 'would not' regret clustering around 10-20% (NZ 2026: 11% would change; Brexit Leave voters: 16% would switch; US 2024: 2-13% explicit regret), then adjusted for this candidate.

Independent estimates: 22% regret / 66% would do it again — combined by averaging in log-odds.

Against this forecast: The strongest case the forecast is wrong in either direction: (low) retrospective 'vote the same way again' stickiness is high even for far more salient and controversial votes (72-85% say same again), a low-salience ward vote is even stickier, and as an opposition councillor she cannot be blamed for the Tory council's failures — so regret could sit near 0.10. (high) Conversely, if Labour wins a Fareham ward where it did not even field a candidate in May 2026, the win is likely a by-election protest fluke; protest coalitions collapse fastest, and by the next contest a large share of her voters will be Green, Lib Dem or Reform-leaning and will happily tell pollsters they would not repeat the vote, pushing regret toward 0.30+.

Raw output from each forecasting pass

Pass 1:

{
  "reference_class": "Retrospective 'would you vote the same way again' polls after national and local votes (post-election surveys of recent voters): typically 72-85% say they would vote the same way again, with explicit 'would not' regret clustering around 10-20% (NZ 2026: 11% would change; Brexit Leave voters: 16% would switch; US 2024: 2-13% explicit regret)",
  "base_rate": 0.18,
  "mechanisms": [
    {
      "mechanism": "If elected, she would be one of at most two Labour councillors on a Conservative-run council (Conservatives hold 22 of 32 seats), so precinct investment, a youth space and free parking protection would be blocked by the ruling group her voters expect her to deliver against",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/election/2026/england/councils/E07000087"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "Her winning coalition would be fragile and new: Labour did not even stand in Portchester Wicor in May 2026, so her voters would include tactical anti-Conservative/anti-Reform voters (about 40% of Labour's 2026 local voters voted tactically), and tactical/protest voters are the most likely to say they would vote differently next time",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://yougov.com/en-gb/articles/54811-labours-voter-coalition-broke-more-to-left-than-right-at-2026-local-elections"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "National Labour unpopularity would continue eroding her soft supporters: only 46% of 2024 Labour voters stayed loyal at the 2026 locals, with 22% switching to the Greens, so some of her voters will have drifted and disavowed the vote by the retrospective",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://yougov.com/en-gb/articles/54811-labours-voter-coalition-broke-more-to-left-than-right-at-2026-local-elections"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "Several headline pledges (A27 noise-camera trial, sea defences and landfill, precinct regeneration) sit with National Highways, the Environment Agency or the council executive, so non-delivery will be visible to her voters well before the next contest",
      "direction": "increase",
      "evidence": "https://candidates.democracyclub.org.uk/person/129193/"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "Her vote is substantially personal — 20+ years in Portchester, chair of governors, Warm Hub and School Uniform Exchange — and personally-known local candidates generate loyal supporters who keep saying they would vote the same way",
      "direction": "decrease",
      "evidence": "https://www.portsmouth.co.uk/news/politics/meet-the-five-candidates-battling-for-portchester-council-seat-9328718"
    },
    {
      "mechanism": "Her statement frames her as a challenger who will 'keep pushing' rather than a deliverer, and she has self-contained quick wins (bringing the School Uniform Exchange to Portchester, casework on fly-tipping and speeding) achievable even in opposition, so expectations are set low and partially met",
      "direction": "decrease",
      "evidence": "https://candidates.democracyclub.org.uk/person/129193/"
    }
  ],
  "counterargument": "The strongest case the forecast is wrong in either direction: (low) retrospective 'vote the same way again' stickiness is high even for far more salient and controversial votes (72-85% say same again), a low-salience ward vote is even stickier, and as an opposition councillor she cannot be blamed for the Tory council's failures — so regret could sit near 0.10. (high) Conversely, if Labour wins a Fareham ward where it did not even field a candidate in May 2026, the win is likely a by-election protest fluke; protest coalitions collapse fastest, and by the next contest a large share of her voters will be Green, Lib Dem or Reform-leaning and will happily tell pollsters they would not repeat the vote, pushing regret toward 0.30+.",
  "reasons": [
    {
      "reason": "Tory-run council blocks her agenda: as one of at most two Labour councillors she cannot deliver precinct investment, a youth space or parking protection",
      "weight": 0.3
    },
    {
      "reason": "Tactical and protest voters who built her winning coalition in a ward Labour didn't contest in May 2026 drift back and disavow the vote",
      "weight": 0.25
    },
    {
      "reason": "National Labour unpopularity keeps shedding her soft supporters (only 46% Labour loyalty at the 2026 locals)",
      "weight": 0.2
    },
    {
      "reason": "Pledges on the A27 noise camera and sea defences depend on outside bodies and visibly go nowhere before the next contest",
      "weight": 0.15
    },
    {
      "reason": "The long gap to the next Portchester Wicor contest gives time for disillusionment and forgetting her personal appeal",
      "weight": 0.1
    }
  ],
  "endorse_reasons": [
    {
      "reason": "Her deep personal roots (20+ years, chair of governors, Warm Hub, uniform exchange) give her a loyal personal vote that stays with her",
      "weight": 0.3
    },
    {
      "reason": "Her 'keep pushing / challenge the Council' framing sets low delivery expectations, so blocked promises are blamed on the Tory council, not on her",
      "weight": 0.25
    },
    {
      "reason": "Low-salience ward votes show high retrospective stickiness — most voters asked 'would you vote the same way again' default to yes",
      "weight": 0.25
    },
    {
      "reason": "Self-contained quick wins like bringing the School Uniform Exchange to Portchester and visible casework give her voters concrete reasons to be glad they voted for her",
      "weight": 0.2
    }
  ],
  "regret_probability": 0.22,
  "endorse_probability": 0.66
}

We'll compare this with what voters say at the next election for this seat.

Earlier forecasts for this candidate
MadeRegret forecastMethodology
2026-11-15 22:29:1821%regret-v2
2026-11-15 01:41:4921%regret-v1

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:01:04.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:9db14512be971a1a… · verify

What we could not verify

Sources

Lorraine Drinkwater - Candidate for Portchester Wicor in Fareham local election (Democracy Club) · Meet the candidates battling for Portchester council seat - Daily Echo · Meet the five candidates battling for Portchester council seat - The News (Portsmouth) · Forthcoming By-Elections - ALDC · Fareham Borough Council elections 2026: Full list of results - Daily Echo · Hampshire County Council election results for The News' area - The News (Portsmouth) · Upcoming council by-elections: projections, candidates and results - PollCheck · St George's Beneficial Church of England (Voluntary Controlled) Primary School - GOV.UK

If elected, then…

Predictions of what would happen if these candidates are elected. Each one reads "if the candidate is elected, then …" — the framing is already here, so write just the outcome. Anyone can post one; it must be specific and falsifiable or it is not posted. Upvote what you think is relevant, downvote what isn't — the most upvoted predictions are analysed for every candidate on the daily run.

Post a prediction

If the candidate is elected, then…

If elected, a road resurfacing scheme for the Portchester Wicor ward will be funded in the 2027/28 capital programme.
Steve Shaw: 19% · Paul Kimber: 18% · Harry Patrick Davis: 16% · Lorraine Drinkwater: 15% · George William Ponsford: 12%
CandidateLikelihood if electedWhy
Steve Shaw19%

This is unlikely because Fareham Borough Council is a district authority, not the highway authority for Portchester; road resurfacing is normally the responsibility of Hampshire County Council and its capital programme, so election to Fareham Borough Council would not give Steve Shaw direct power to fund it. Even if it were a borough matter, a single ward councillor cannot guarantee a line in the 2027/28 capital programme, which requires council-wide budget approval and officer prioritisation. Decisive factors: Fareham Borough Council is not the highways authority; Hampshire County Council controls road resurfacing and its capital programme; An individual councillor cannot unilaterally commit council capital funds; full council/executive budget approval is required; No evidence that a specific Portchester Wicor resurfacing scheme has been pre-agreed or included in the draft 2027/28 programme; Political control and wider budget constraints determine which capital schemes are prioritised.

Made by an earlier analysis run, which recorded only the basis.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:53.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:ac2e93aedfe40a0e… · verify

Paul Kimber18%

Even if elected, Paul Kimber would be one Reform UK councillor on Fareham Borough Council, which does not control highway resurfacing—that is a Hampshire County Council function—so he could at most lobby for a Portchester Wicor scheme rather than ensure it is funded in Fareham's 2027/28 capital programme. The dossier also contains no explicit road-resurfacing promise, only broader road-safety and spending-priority pledges. Decisive factors: Road resurfacing is primarily a Hampshire County Council responsibility, not a Fareham Borough Council capital function; No explicit commitment in Kimber's dossier to a Portchester Wicor resurfacing scheme in 2027/28; A single opposition councillor would lack the votes to guarantee inclusion in the council's capital programme; No identified funding source or prior council budget commitment for this specific scheme.

Made by an earlier analysis run, which recorded only the basis.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:52.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:b3e7ea616ef71299… · verify

Harry Patrick Davis16%

If elected, Davis would be one Fareham borough councillor; road resurfacing is normally a Hampshire County Council highways function, and he has not made it a stated priority, so a specific Portchester Wicor scheme being funded in Fareham's 2027/28 capital programme would require separate budget decisions he could only marginally influence. Decisive factors: Highway authority responsibility lies with Hampshire County Council, not Fareham Borough Council; No road-resurfacing pledge appears among Davis's stated priorities; Capital programme funding depends on council-wide budget prioritisation and officer assessments; A single councillor's election does not guarantee a named ward scheme.

Made by an earlier analysis run, which recorded only the basis.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:52.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:c7f9aa67eaee9c79… · verify

Lorraine Drinkwater15%

Unlikely: even if Lorraine Drinkwater is elected, a single Labour councillor would not control Fareham Borough Council's capital programme, and road resurfacing is primarily a Hampshire County Council highways responsibility rather than a borough budget item. She has not made a Portchester Wicor road-resurfacing scheme a campaign promise, so there is no clear mechanism for it to be funded in 2027/28. Decisive factors: No road-resurfacing scheme appears among her published campaign priorities; Road resurfacing is mainly Hampshire County Council's function, not Fareham Borough Council's; A single ward councillor cannot ensure inclusion in the council's capital programme without majority/administration support; She is a Labour candidate in a by-election with no established Labour incumbency or control of the council.

Made by an earlier analysis run, which recorded only the basis.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:52.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:2fb407b52754fde4… · verify

George William Ponsford12%

This specific resurfacing pledge does not appear in Ponsford's published platform, and even if he were elected, a single Restore Britain backbench councillor could not unilaterally fund a ward scheme in Fareham's 2027/28 capital programme; that requires officer prioritisation, budget approval and majority council support. Decisive factors: No evidence Ponsford has made road resurfacing a campaign promise or priority; Restore Britain is a new fringe party and Ponsford is a first-time candidate with no council influence; Capital programme funding is a collective council budget decision, not a single-councillor power; His election in Portchester Wicor is unlikely, making the conditional premise weak.

Made by an earlier analysis run, which recorded only the basis.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:51.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:ad08dd493962d180… · verify

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:01:04.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:eade2b8dadd4e2e2… · verify

2 ·

If elected, they will vote for the next Fareham Borough Council budget.
Harry Patrick Davis: 82% · Steve Shaw: 82% · Lorraine Drinkwater: 80% · George William Ponsford: 77% · Paul Kimber: 75%
CandidateLikelihood if electedWhy
Harry Patrick Davis82%

Very likely: as a Conservative councillor, Davis would be expected to follow his party group's line on the annual budget, and Fareham budget votes are normally whipped and party-line. If the Conservatives remain in administration, he would almost certainly vote for their budget; only if they are in opposition to a rival budget would he likely vote against it. Decisive factors: Conservative Party affiliation and group discipline; Whether Conservatives control the council administration; Budget votes are typically treated as party-line or confidence votes; No record of rebellion or independent budget stance.

Made by an earlier analysis run, which recorded only the basis.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:54.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:5466a52640dab882… · verify

Steve Shaw82%

As a Liberal Democrat councillor, Steve Shaw would be expected to follow the Lib Dem group's position on Fareham Borough Council's annual budget. He would likely vote for it only if the Lib Dem group supports or negotiates a deal on the budget; if the group opposes it, he would almost certainly vote against. Decisive factors: Party group discipline and whip on budget votes; Whether the Liberal Democrats are in the council administration or opposition; Budget contents and whether the Lib Dem group supports or opposes it; Risk of absence or abstention, though this is rare on budget votes.

Made by an earlier analysis run, which recorded only the basis.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:55.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:3f37737c0efebc67… · verify

Lorraine Drinkwater80%

Drinkwater would sit as a single Labour councillor in opposition on Fareham Borough Council, and budget votes are whipped party votes; a Labour member is therefore far more likely to oppose an administration budget put forward by another party than to vote in favour of it, unless Labour were part of the ruling administration or the budget were genuinely cross-party. Decisive factors: Party group discipline: budget votes at council level are treated as whipped, so her vote would follow the Labour group line rather than personal preference; Likely political composition of the council/administration proposing the budget, and whether Labour is in power or opposition; Whether the budget is contested or agreed cross-party (her stated willingness to work cross-party when it gets things done); Low salience of this specific procedural pledge in her campaign material — no budget stance is mentioned among her promises.

Made by an earlier analysis run, which recorded only the basis.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:55.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:ebf5e8d2d6b776ec… · verify

George William Ponsford77%

As a Restore Britain councillor, Ponsford would be an opposition member facing a budget proposed by the incumbent administration, and he has made no pledge to support it; his party's anti-establishment stance makes a yes vote unlikely unless the budget explicitly aligns with his priorities. Decisive factors: No candidate-specific budget pledge or policy platform; Restore Britain is an opposition/insurgent party likely to oppose the incumbent administration's budget; Local council budget votes are typically partisan, with opposition councillors voting against; Unknown budget content (e.g., council tax rise, spending priorities) could trigger opposition.

Made by an earlier analysis run, which recorded only the basis.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:53.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:a9e6d46340c63fdf… · verify

Paul Kimber75%

As a Reform UK opposition candidate with no role in the ruling administration and a campaign centred on challenging council spending, Paul Kimber would likely vote against the next Fareham Borough Council budget unless it were cross-party or heavily reflected Reform priorities. The statement is therefore unlikely to hold. Decisive factors: Reform UK is not identified as controlling Fareham Borough Council or setting the budget; Local budget votes usually follow party group lines, so an opposition councillor would be expected to oppose a rival administration's budget; His stated promises emphasise challenging spending, opposing 'vanity projects' and not accepting 'there's no money' answers; No evidence suggests he would be in a ruling coalition or that the budget would incorporate his demands.

Made by an earlier analysis run, which recorded only the basis.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:55.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:45fd0b0efd50aa3b… · verify

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:01:04.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:749230975ad67e9f… · verify

0 ·

If elected, they will still sit in the same party group at the annual council meeting in May 2027.
Harry Patrick Davis: 86% · Lorraine Drinkwater: 82% · Steve Shaw: 81% · Paul Kimber: 79% · George William Ponsford: 61%
CandidateLikelihood if electedWhy
Harry Patrick Davis86%

If elected, Davis would almost certainly take his seat as a Conservative councillor and continue to sit with the Conservative party group, since he is standing for that party and there is no indication he would defect or be expelled before May 2027. Decisive factors: He is the Conservative and Unionist Party candidate and a former Conservative councillor.; Party group affiliation is normally stable over the roughly six months between the November 2026 by-election and the May 2027 annual council meeting.; There is no evidence of an intended defection, expulsion, or independent candidacy..

Made by an earlier analysis run, which recorded only the basis.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:56.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:30c01b2dff99e61d… · verify

Lorraine Drinkwater82%

As an explicitly Labour candidate, Lorraine Drinkwater would be expected to join the Labour group if elected, and the roughly six months until the May 2027 annual council meeting is a short period in which only an unusual defection, expulsion, or group reorganisation would change that. The dossier contains no signs of an independent candidacy, party dispute, or intention to leave Labour. Decisive factors: She is standing for the Labour Party with no independent or defection signals.; The interval from the November 2026 by-election to May 2027 is short.; Fareham Borough Council's party-group rules would normally keep an elected Labour councillor in the Labour group.; No known disciplinary, expulsion, or local party split is reported that would force a change..

Made by an earlier analysis run, which recorded only the basis.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:56.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:f4737beb0fd7f24b… · verify

Steve Shaw81%

Steve Shaw is standing and campaigning as a Liberal Democrat and explicitly says he would work with the local Lib Dem councillor; if elected, he would be expected to join and remain in the Liberal Democrat group at least until the May 2027 annual meeting. There is no evidence of an intention to defect or sit as an independent, so the main risk is an unexpected falling-out or group split in the short period after the by-election. Decisive factors: He is the Liberal Democrat candidate and his campaign is aligned with the local Lib Dem group; No indication he would defect or sit as an independent; The predecessor left the Lib Dem group for health reasons, not because of a broader party split, so limited precedent for Shaw; Short interval between the November 2026 by-election and the May 2027 annual meeting reduces time for affiliation to change.

Made by an earlier analysis run, which recorded only the basis.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:57.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:ae7e01508ea41e96… · verify

Paul Kimber79%

Party group membership on a council is essentially a function of the party label a councillor is elected under, and councillors almost never switch or leave their group within the first six months of a term; Kimber is a committed Reform UK candidate who has stood twice for the party and shows no sign of independent or cross-party positioning. Absent a suspension, defection or resignation, he would be recorded as a Reform UK group member at the May 2027 annual meeting. Decisive factors: Strong and consistent Reform UK affiliation (Avenue 2026 and Portchester Wicor 2026 candidacies, active work with Reform's Hampshire county councillors); Very short time horizon (~6 months from the November 2026 by-election to the May 2027 annual meeting), over which group changes are rare; No evidence of independent status, whip removal, or defection risk in the dossier; Council annual meetings normally confirm existing group affiliations rather than reassign members.

Made by an earlier analysis run, which recorded only the basis.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:57.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:aa2c2328e7552203… · verify

George William Ponsford61%

If elected, Ponsford would be expected to take his seat as a Restore Britain councillor and, absent a party split or personal defection, still be affiliated with that party group at the May 2027 annual meeting. The short six-month interval and lack of any reported factional dispute make a change unlikely, though Restore Britain's newness and possible single-councillor status create some uncertainty about formal group recognition. Decisive factors: Short time horizon between the November 2026 by-election and the May 2027 annual meeting; No evidence of defection risk, factional dispute, or party collapse; Restore Britain's new and potentially unstable status as a minor far-right party; Fareham council rules on whether a single councillor can constitute a recognised party group.

Made by an earlier analysis run, which recorded only the basis.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:00:56.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:0cb02d3883cb08f1… · verify

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:01:05.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:869a9ae6e413774b… · verify

0 ·

They will host a dance party
Queued for analysis on the daily run.

Committed at 2026-11-16T12:01:05.000Z (RFC 3161 timestamp) — sha256:04ee6006b24865fe… · verify

0 ·

P(regret|vote)